Instagram @lizchewy

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

Urban Decay Naked & Naked 2 Review

Hi everyone. I am going to be a laggard in blogland and review the Urban Decay Naked and Naked 2 palettes, which I am sure most of you would have heard/seen/own. I have recently acquired the Naked 2 palette, so I have decided to do review it alongside with my ever-so-loved Naked palette.


ORIGINAL NAKED PALETTE
The original Naked palette. The packaging: cardboard covered with felt/velvet (not too sure what it is but it's along those lines) with magnetic closure.


Comes with 12 eyeshadows: (from left) Virgin, Sin, Naked, Sidecar, Buck, Half Baked, Smog, Darkhorse, Toasted, Hustle, Creep and Gunmetal. It also comes with a mini Urban Decay primer potion and mine also came with a dual-ended Urban Decay 24/7 glide on liner pencil (one side is whiskey and one side is zero).
Mine is an older version I got on ebay a while back, the newer Naked palette no longer comes with a dual ended pencil but instead it comes with a dual ended brush (*correction: the ones now come with a single-ended eyeshadow brush). 


From left: Virgin (shimmery white, but not stark white, maybe more like eggshell white), Sin (pinkish champagne beige), Naked (matte medium brown), Sidecar (shimmery brown with silver sheen), Buck (matte chocolate brown) and Half Baked (yellow tone gold).


From left: Smog (coppery brown with copper sheen), Darkhorse (shimmery taupe), Toasted (rose gold-tinge copper), Hustle (charcoal brown with pink and purple sparkle), Creep (dark grey, almost black with multi colour shimmer) and Gunmetal (gunmetal grey with metallic light blue sheen).

As you can see in the pictures this palette has been well loved by me. I have yellow undertone skin and the warm browns in this palette looks nice against my skin tone. This palette has an excellent mix from light to dark, matte to shimmer that can really create a myriad of neutral looks (from extremely natural to heavy makeup looks). Urban Decay shadows are not the smoothest or silkiest eyeshadows in the market, but it is definitely in the higher side of the quadrant. The shadows can be prone to fallout but it's not too bad as long as you tap off the excess. The shadows are pigmented and wears well, lasts for over 8 hours on my lids but starts fading gradually from hour 6 or so.

One thing I don't like about the palette is the packaging. I don't mind the magnetic closure despite some people saying that it can flip open when you put it in your luggage (I have traveled several times with this palette and I have never had that happen to me). I just think that the finish of the packaging makes it attract dust and dirt like crazy, and there's no way you can clean it properly. 

My favourite colours: Sin as a browbone and inner corner highlight as well as all over lid colour to brighten the lids; Naked as an all over lid colour to create some depth and dimension, especially when I am doing the no-makeup makeup look; Buck to fill in my brows, define the lash line or to set eyeliners; Smog to apply in the lower half of my lids and outer corners.

There's 3 colours in this palette that I personally don't quite like. One, Sidecar because it's messy and has lots of fallout. Two is Half Baked, which I don't think looks nice against my skin tone because of the strong yellow tone in it. And lastly, Creep because the base colour is patchy and both the shadow and shimmers are prone to fallout.

NAKED 2 PALETTE
Tadahhhh~~ This is what the packaging looks like for those who hasn't seen it before. It reminds me so much of the metal pencil cases I own as a little kid.

Let's have a look at the lip junkie and brush first before moving on to the actual eyeshadows.
Instead of a mini size Urban Decay eyeshadow primer potion, this palette comes with a mini lip junkie in the colour Naked.

The Naked Lip Junkie is a peachy pink colour with lots of shimmer. The gloss is not very opaque but it does tinge my lips a little, shimmers are not overly apparent unless you look very closely. This gloss is supposed to be cooling and lip plumping, but I really don't notice much of that on my lips. The texture is not too thick and sticky, so the gloss is quite comfortable to wear. The smell is of mint candy, which I think is so delicious. This Lip Junkie wears like a typical gloss for me, which is around 2 hours plus and I will definitely need to reapply after I eat/drink/talk too much.


The palette also comes with a dual ended synthetic brush (one end is a fluffy blending brush and the other is a typical eyeshadow brush that is good for laying down colours).

I don't really care for this brush and I don't use it at all. The bristle are alright, on the stiffer side but not to the point that it's scratchy. I personally just don't really like the way this brush feels on the lids but it is a convenient brush to have if you don't already have lots of brushes. 


Comes with 12 eyeshadows. From left: Foxy, Half Baked, Bootycall, Chopper, Tease, Snakebite, Suspect, Pistol, Verve, YDK, Busted and Blackout.


From left: Foxy (matte creamy beige), Half Baked (same as the one in Naked yellow tone gold), Bootycall (shimmery off white, similar to Virgin), Chopper (rose gold), Tease (matte mauve tinge taupe), Snakebite (brown with copper sheen).


From left: Suspect (medium taupe with sheen), Pistol (grey with silver sheen), Verve (metallic dirty white, you know what I mean? like when you are mixing paints and you accidentally get a little black into the white colour?), YDK (metallic coppery brown with copper sheen and shimmers), Busted (Dark brown) and Blackout (matte black).

I haven't had the Naked 2 palette for very long at all so I haven't used it a whole lot and I still have mixed feelings for it. The Naked 2 shadows are of Urban Decay's updated shadow formula (as in the Urban Decay 15th anniversary palette, Book of shadows 4, I think, and in the recently relaunched single shadows). The texture is definitely slightly smoother and creamier but I don't think the difference is all that life changing for me. There is also again, a good mix of light-dark, matte-shimmer shadows which makes this palette very versatile. I haven't tried out all the shades on the lids but the ones that I have tried wears quite well, I had my makeup on for 7 hours or so and it still looked quite good. I also much prefer Naked 2's packaging, the metal case is much sturdier, the mirror is much bigger and it doesn't get dirty as easily (even if it did get dirty I can just wipe it clean!!!).

I think the shadows in the Naked 2 are more cool toned, so I don't necessarily like some of the shades against my skin tone. 

My favourite shades: Foxy as a highlight colour when I want to add some brightness without it being too in your face, Snakebite to be applied in the outer corner for definition and Busted to define the lash line or to create a smokey liner look.

Colours I don't really like and haven't used: YDK has lots of fallout; Verve, which faded and spread in the time it took for me to swatch and take photos of the shadows (less than 30 minutes). And Half Baked, which I still don't think looks good on my skin but lots of people like it.

COMPARISON
 As you can see, the Naked 2's packaging is just much sturdier and cleaner looking. Size of the palettes are similar.


I really like the light to dark progression of the colours in the Naked palette but for some reason Urban Decay didn't do it the same way in the Naked 2.


Colour comparisons. Top from left Virgin, Sin, Naked, Sidecar, Buck, Half Baked, Smog, Darkhorse, Toasted, Hustle, Creep and Gunmetal. 
Bottom from left Foxy, Half Baked, Bootycall, Chopper, Tease, Snakebite, Suspect, Pistol, Verve, YDK, Busted and Blackout.

Half Baked in Naked and Naked 2 are identical, as they are the same shade.
Virgin and Bootycall looks similar on the lids, but Bootycall is warmer.
Snakebite reminds me of Smog, but more brown.
Suspect looks similar to Sidecar, but with a more apparent sheen. The colour reminds me of the colour Naked but of course suspect has a sheen.

Bottom line is, these are both very good palettes. They are both versatile and contains a good mix of tones and textures. Albeit being of different formulas, the shadows are mostly pigmented, the texture are nice and wears well on the lids. Whichever you will prefer will largely depends on your preference towards the nuances of neutral tones that you prefer to wear. 

I think the average non-makeup-junkie people definitely will not need both of these and if I have to choose one, it will be the original Naked palette.



 My everyday neutral makeup using the Naked 2 palette. I used Foxy all over the lid as a colour wash, then I applied Bootycall in the front half of my eyes and on the lower lash line. I also applied Tease on the lower half of my lids to define my eyes and Snakebite on the outer corners.

This is it from me this time. Please follow me on twitter at http://twitter.com/lizchewy and/or weibo http://www.weibo.com/lizchewy

Until next time xoxo

47 comments:

  1. thank you sooo much:)
    like your blog!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice review and comparison! :) I haven't tried either so I might just go for number 2 if I do end up buying one of them.. probably lol.
    Thanks for sharing hun :)
    xx

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think I'd probably suit the second one as I have cool undertones and my skin is more pinky based than yellow.

    I love seeing the Urban Decay palettes, I know that they're popular in the blogging world but I've never really checked them out myself, so it's nice to see photos of it all! xx

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks for this! <3

    you look really cute. Love the blush you're wearing! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I really want to get it, thank you for the review really helpful! ^^

    ReplyDelete
  6. Wow, nice colors and palette. I am not a makeup person but these colors make me want to try these! X

    ReplyDelete
  7. Thanks for the swatches! I have still yet to buy this. :c

    ReplyDelete
  8. i like sidecar and half baked! :D

    <3, Mimi
    http://whatmimiwrites.blogspot.com/
    $100 Shopbop Gift Card Giveaway -- Open internationally!

    ReplyDelete
  9. seems like everyone loves this <3

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great review! I was curious about the differences between the original and Naked2.
    I'm thinking if I ever get it, it'll have to be the first one :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. wow thanks so much for the review of these palates and comparing them to each other! i've been wanting to buy the Naked palettes (i've heard so much good things about them!) though i have heard that the original one is better in terms of color and i can see you agree too!

    alex @ carouselstreet.com

    ReplyDelete
  12. Love this pallet need one so bad haha
    you are beautiful :)
    xoxo
    http://www.scarlletgs.blogspot.com.br/

    ReplyDelete
  13. Great post: I like this palette so much!!
    What about following each other? Cosa mi metto???
    Win a wonderful long dress from Shabby Apple

    ReplyDelete
  14. Beautiful make up! It also looks very good on you :) it's so subtle! XX

    ReplyDelete
  15. I like your reviews, they are always very helpful!

    ReplyDelete
  16. So many colours - those palettes will probably last you a lifetime!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Wow awesome long review I LOVE!!!!! I wanted to get naked palette for the longest time but just find it a little pricey for the 12 colours since I already have most of the colours from my other palettes!! And I bet there'll be a huge line up when the H&M first open in Malaysia cause I heard that's what happen in hk when it open. Me on the other hand would like to travel to Malaysia cause I wanna try out all of the food there (seen it in a lot of my friend's pictures) and I love durian :b

    ang-closet365.blogspot.ca

    ReplyDelete
  18. You know, I've been debating for the longest time whether or not I should get Naked 2, and so far all the reviews I've read seemed to say that Naked > Naked 2. I love the swatch comparison you did, and honestly the colors are really too similar to justify getting the 2nd one. Guess I'll just be sticking with my Naked :P

    ReplyDelete
  19. Wow what a amazing review! I really like the first palette, I think more than the second actually - probably because the primer is included which sounds amazing!
    Thanks for the wonderfully informative review!
    xx



    The Urban Umbrella
    xoxo


    http://www.theurbanumbrella.com/

    ReplyDelete
  20. i really want one of these. looks so great
    thanks for the comment. xx

    ReplyDelete
  21. hi just came across your blog! and wow very in depth review of the naked palettes. I have both of these too, love themmm~~ come check out and follow my blog if you'd like <3

    xoxo,
    http://miss-6.blogspot.ca/

    ReplyDelete
  22. never tried these but I like their products!


    http://fashion-gourmet.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  23. great and useful post! i'm looking forward to the naked 2 hope to get it asap!

    Hope you can check my latest outfit post! Wait for you!

    xoxo

    www.timelessismore.com

    ReplyDelete
  24. ohh the naked palette is awesome, one of my favourites! I haven't tried the naked 2 though but and love what you did with it I have to check it out!

    ReplyDelete
  25. i've never actually tried these palettes but i'm dying to still! love all the neutrals in one place

    x Jordan
    - Boho Vanity -

    ReplyDelete
  26. I really love Urban Decay. These palettes are fantastic. I use them all the time.

    http://www.glamkittenslitterbox.com/
    Twitter: @GlamKitten88

    ReplyDelete
  27. Such a great review! Just made me want this palette even more!

    www.rougefox.com

    ReplyDelete
  28. Those colors are so pretty! P.S. I thought you would be interested in the giveaway I'm hosting for eShakti on www.domesticsweetheart.com

    ReplyDelete
  29. HAVE A GOOD TIME IN THE WEEKEND :)
    great palette as always!! ure the queen for this.

    ReplyDelete
  30. Awesome colour palette...this is exactly what I wear to go out! Those exact colours. Graet review x

    Couture Caddy

    ReplyDelete
  31. These palettes look like all you could ever need!!

    Whimisically,

    Kel

    ReplyDelete
  32. You did a great job with this comparison post! I agree that I like the Naked 1 palette more as well. I haven't purchased the 2nd one, but a lot of the colors just look a bit too similar to the ones in the original for me to warrant the purchase. I also don't like how the shades aren't arranged from light to dark - it looks kinda messy compared to the original and like they just threw in all the colors at random.

    ReplyDelete
  33. i really want the naked palettes! Looks so nice!

    www.myladyboudoir.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  34. very nice palette I'm seeing this everywhere lately xo
    thanks for commenting on my blog honey, would you like to follow each other?
    A
    xx
    http://epiquemoi.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  35. Great palette! woow!! its really nice!!♥
    I like it!! :D
    Have a nice day!♥
    http://thehiddenroots.blogspot.mx/

    ReplyDelete
  36. Great review, the color palette on the urban decay shadow is amazing, and you look beautiful in it! Your blog is lovely, if you want to take a look at mine it’s at http://www.grassettagillie.com, if you’d like we should follow each other! :)

    xo Gillie

    ReplyDelete
  37. such a beautiful girl

    ReplyDelete
  38. great review :)

    I'm planning on buying naked 1 but I prefer the brush and the outside of naked2 T__T Don't know which to choose :( hmm if you don't use the brush in naked2 palette, I really one to have it XD LOL~jk~ :(

    ReplyDelete
  39. Hi~ Naked 1 comes with a brush instead of the dual-ended eyeliner now. If you prefer warm tones eyeshadows, then original Naked. If you like cool tone neutrals, then go with Naked 2 ^-^

    ReplyDelete
  40. Is the Urban Decay Naked 2 made in China?

    ReplyDelete
  41. The eyeshadows are made in the USA and the brush included in the palette is made in China.

    ReplyDelete
  42. Thanks for your swatches and review! ^^ .. I ended up choosing Naked 2 because of the casing.. :( .. I kind of regret it because the colors of the Naked palette definitely look more varied and possibly better for an Asian complexion .. If anything, it seems it'll look better in photographs because it contains more matte colors. Thanks again :]

    ReplyDelete
  43. Thank you for reading my review and leaving a comment~ If I remember correctly, the Naked 1 has 2 matte shades whereas the Naked 2 has 3 matte shades :) Everyone has different preferences but I personally think that the Naked 1 will work better for people with yellow/warm skin tone.

    ReplyDelete

Thank you so much for visiting my blog ♥

Google Ads